Leibish & Co. Diamonds Review: Are they legit?

Sharif Khan
Sharif Khan
Last Updated    EST 
Affiliate links are highlighted in red. Learn more here.

In 1979, Leibish Polnauer had just discovered that the company he worked for, a polishing firm, was being shut down. That same day, he found an advert in a newspaper by Garrad & Co., looking for a rare diamond. Leibish took the risk and traveled three continents to find the diamonds Garrad & Co asked for.

This led to Leibish founding Leibish & Co, a family-run business known for being one of the largest buyers at the Argyle Tender, held annually.

Leibish & Co is responsible for pioneering online diamond retailing, starting in 1995, and the company supplies some of the largest luxury jewelers, such as Graff.

The business has become the largest supplier of fancy-colored diamonds globally.

Compare Leibish & Co Diamonds with James Allen.

Leibish & Co
  • 4.5 out of 5
    Product Quality
  • 4.2 out of 5
    Product Diversity
  • 4.5 out of 5
    Customer Service
  • 4 out of 5
    Sustainability
  • 4 out of 5
    Price
  • 4 out of 5
    Website Use

      What Leibish & Co. Offer

      Leibish & Co. prides itself on providing customers with the best product: fancy colored diamonds in a large range of shapes, clarities, sizes, and hues that suit different budgets and tastes. Experts at Leibish & Co travel globally to find the finest stones to retail on the site, ensuring that all diamonds sourced are naturally mined, either in Africa, Russia, India, or Australia, with GIA certificates and certified conflict-free.

      Leibish & Co. also believes these incredible diamonds need the perfect setting, so they offer some of the finest engagement ring mountings online. There are many different styles, and the settings are crafted to bring out the natural hue and saturation of the fancy-cut diamonds.

      Other than the superb quality of the products they offer, Leibish & Co. also works to provide a seamless, enjoyable shopping experience for customers, with expert guidance along the way.

      What Makes Leibish & Co. Stand Out?

      Spectacular Ring Settings – To match the perfect fancy color diamond chosen, Leibish & Co. has a wide selection of beautiful jewelry to enhance the unique characteristics of a stone. The metal components of the ring are crafted expertly to make the most of the natural beauty of the diamond. There is a setting to match any diamond you choose.

      Certification – All diamonds, stones, and jewelry sold by Leibish & Co. come with in-house GIA or IGI certifications or certificates. All stones are also conflict-free and sourced from natural mines through ethical procurement.

      Expert Craftsmanship – Each piece of jewelry on the site, chosen to be paired with a fancy colored diamond, is created with the right combination of metals and alloys to improve the top-view color intensity of the diamond. For example, yellow-colored diamonds are often set in a yellow-gold basket to enhance the warmth of the stone. 3D profiling scans are done of the diamonds before setting them to help design the custom setting properly.

      Leibish & Co. Pricing

      Leibish & Co. owns all the diamonds displayed on their site, which allows them to offer the diamonds at a competitive price compared to other vendors who need to increase their diamond prices to offset high inventory costs.

      As a wholesale company, the prices of fancy colored stones and other gems are fairly competitive, but the high quality of the stones brings about a higher premium. James Allen also features fancy colored diamonds and is a direct competitor to Leibish & Co, thanks to the pricing of the fancy-colored diamonds that James Allen offers.

      Being one of the few online retailers that sell fancy color diamonds, the prices may be more premium, but the rarity and quality of the stones give you value.

      Custom Orders

      Leibish & Co. offers clients the option to custom design their own rings, with a user-friendly process to create a ring tailored to the client's vision.

      The site has a three-step requirement with easy-to-follow steps where you will choose your diamond and your setting and then complete the request. While this does not offer customers the chance to design their own ring from the beginning, it does offer the freedom to match a desired diamond with a chosen setting.

      Website Ease of Use

      Opening the online Leibish & Co. site, you are greeted with a pleasant pop of color thanks to the design of the page and the fancy color diamond images. Keeping the clean, appealing home page trend, the Leibish & Co. site is modern and neat.

      The site is easy to navigate, with big, bold text that guides you to find the diamond, jewelry, or information you might need.

      Some helpful filtering options are available on the site, allowing you to narrow your search to find exactly what you want. A whole host of important information is shown with each stone and piece of jewelry, providing all the information a customer might need to decide on a purchase.

      All diamonds are imaged and displayed, and their specific prices, properties, and availability are clearly shown. This makes shopping at Leibish & Co. an absolute pleasure.

      Customer Service

      Leibish & Co. looks to provide great customer service wherever possible. Being in the market for decades, they have built up reliable and knowledgeable customer service and after-purchase service that does care for customers.

      Full-time Customer Support – There is an instant chat option on their site, where you are connected immediately to a knowledgeable and helpful customer care agent who can assist with any queries.

      Return Policy – Leibish & Co. offers a 30-day money-back guarantee on purchases made.

      Warranty – There is a full warranty on products for any manufacturing defects.

      Free Shipping – There is an overnight insured shipping option for all products, and most items are shipped within 48 hours.

      Leibish & Co. Financing Options

      Customers can use external financing options such as PayPal Credit and Split It when shopping at Leibish & Co. Other than these options, layaway plans are available for certain products. Still, these are set out according to the cost of the purchase.

      Why You Should Choose Leibish & Co.?

      • Large inventory of in-house owned fancy-colored diamonds
      • Engagement ring settings suited to enhance the beauty and hues of the fancy diamonds
      • Decades’ worth of experience in the industry help the company achieve only the highest quality of products for retail
      • Free, insured international shipping
      • All diamonds are certified and conflict-free

      Leibish & Co. – Colorful and Exquisite

      For a different, colorful take on engagement rings, Leibish & Co. is the perfect site to explore your options. With incredible customer care, you can custom design your own engagement ring or other jewelry, all crafted to bring out the natural hues and beauty of the stone you choose.

      The experience and years of mastery put into the business show through their exceptional gallery of fancy colored diamonds and perfectly suited jewelry to match.

      Leibish & Co. is fresh air into the diamond and engagement ring industry. Specializing in fancy-color diamonds, their stones are unique and full of character. Nothing is ordinary about the diamonds sold on the site; they are vibrant and beaming with light and color.

      Leibish & Co. should be one of your top choices if you are in the market for fancy colored diamonds. Not only are they one of the largest retailers of fancy colored diamonds online, but the quality is outstanding, pillared on the company's success.